Rest in Peace, Myriam Achkar
This article was edited one day after publishing to clarify that it was attempted rape.
The attempted rape and murder of Myriam Achkar in Sahel Alma has angered and outraged all of us. Myriam’s story is tragic and brings us face to face with the cruelest, most heinous of crimes. We are frustrated and enraged because it is unjust that she dies like this. A young woman, 28, takes a 20-minute walk from her home in the suburbs and gets sexually attacked and then murdered by a man.
That’s really what the story is: A young woman, 28, takes a 20-minute walk from her home in the suburbs and gets sexually attacked and murdered by a man.
But that’s not the story we’re hearing everywhere. What we’re hearing is: A young, Christian, virgin woman, 28, takes a 20-minute walk from her home to a church to pray, and gets sexually attacked and murdered by a Syrian worker.
And so the anger and outrage becomes Christian anger against Syrians. The family thirsts for his blood. They want to lynch him in the public square of Jounieh. They feel wronged as a religious community. This is violence from Syrians towards all Christians, and the Christians are too forgiving, they say. And they stress that Myriam was a practicing believer. She was not out in Gemmayze at 1am, they say. She was on her way to pray.
Nationality and religion have nothing to do with why Myriam was attacked. Really. I am not justifying the murder, God forbid anyone should justify the crime. And the rapist murderer, Fathi Jaber Al-Salatini should be tried, and if convicted, go to jail until he dies. I’m just stating a fact. Nationality and religion have nothing to do with the violence Myriam faced. What time it was, what she was wearing, what she was on her way to do, none of that matters. She was still brutally violated and her barbaric murder was not motivated by theft or hatred. It was motivated by rape.
Her story is, very sadly, not unique. I have heard dozens of stories about rape, from people and from survivors themselves. And so have you. If you haven’t, it just means that the women around you are not talking to you about it. In fact, the women in Lebanon are not talking about rape at all.
Our anger at this horrible crime – understandable anger, human anger – should be towards rape…
Towards the backwards rape laws in Lebanon.
Rapists most often get off the hook. Women are blamed. I don’t have statistics because we don’t have studies. But I know of many cases. Most recently, a European woman was raped and beaten up by two young Lebanese men. I met her and I saw the scars and bruises. The men have posted bail and are now building a case to fight her allegations in court. Our law, Article 503 says a rapist can be acquitted if he marries the victim. He would often get a reduced sentence if he proposes marriage. The maximum sentence is 5 years. Husbands are excluded from this law if they rape their wives. Rape is interpreted as a penis penetrating a vagina. All other forms of sexual violence are not criminalized. This is the law the governs rape in Lebanon. This is the law we should revolt against.
Towards the police who never take rape complaints seriously.
Our police force is not trained to handle rape cases. They ask a woman what she was wearing and why she was where she was. They ask her if she is married. The forensic doctor examines her on the same bed where police officers sleep between shifts. That is if a woman is brave enough or has enough faith in the police to report rape. In one rape case that happened in the summer, a woman had to return to the police station 3 times before they finally wrote down her complaint and promised to investigate it.
Towards the municipalities who don’t provide enough lighting or protection.
Our streets are unsafe. Women are subject to sexual harassment on the streets – any street in any part of Lebanon – 24 hours a day. Lewd comments, stalking, following in a car, propositions for sex, groping, you name it, it happens 24 hours a day to almost every woman, young women especially, every day. And our protective measure, often, is to tell women not to be on that street, at that time, alone. It’s a stupid measure. What we need is municipalities to take sexual harassment seriously, to have enough security that punishes harassment, to have adequate lighting, to respond to complaints. Outside one university campus in Metn is a women’s dorm where men gather every night to harass every woman who enters and exits. They have complained to the university and the municipality and nothing was done about it. When we allow, as a society, sexual violence to be dismissed and joked about and belittled, we allow for rape to go unaddressed.
Towards the sexist culture that promotes the sexual objectification of women.
Women’s bodies are used, haphazardly and illogically, to sell just about anything. Selling taouk? Put a naked women on the ad. Selling a carpet? Put a naked woman on the ad. Selling a gadgets magazine? Put a naked woman on the cover. Everywhere we go, the image of the Lebanese woman we are promoting is one of sex and desire and objectification. There are often no heads on the bodies even, no people behind the bodies. In a media and advertising culture that promotes women as sex objects, how can we raise our girls to love and claim ownership over their own bodies? How can we raise our boys to not feel entitled to consume women’s bodies at their will? How can we call for the sexual liberation of women when we only understand sexual liberation as the commercial objectification of women?
Towards the silencing of women’s stories when they want to talk about rape.
It is extremely difficult for women (here and anywhere) to talk about rape. The shame, the self-blame, the guilt, the taboos, the excuses we give rapists first before we condemn them. In our country, we tell women not to get raped. We don’t tell men not to rape. When they do speak up, we either silence them to protect their “honor” or we ask them a million questions as if it were their fault. Rape is never a woman’s fault. We have not opened up the space, as a women’s movement and as a society, for women to come forward with rape stories and get the justice they deserve. We have not created the proper support systems to give them the services (legal, health, psychological, community support) they need. We have not taught our mothers and fathers to encourage their girls to always speak up, that nothing is taboo, that they must report sexual violence when it happens. We protect our girls by teaching them to always speak up. A woman can survive rape. She always does. Thousands of Lebanese women – your friends, your sisters, your colleagues – have survived rape. What traumatizes them is the guilt and shame they feel because you won’t listen to them or you will blame them or you will make them feel worthless.
Towards the excuses we give rapists.
Boys will be boys. Boys need to have sex, it’s a physiological need. He was her boyfriend, it’s her fault for dating him in the first place. He was turned on by her short skirt. He couldn’t control himself. She looks Russian, he thought she was a sex worker. He misunderstood her and thought she wanted it. She was too drunk. He was seduced by her eyes. She had kissed him so he assumed she wanted to have sex. A million excuses we will give men. Illogical, stupid excuses, all part of a system that won’t teach kids proper sex education but will justify sexual violence when it happens. A culture that equates men’s honor with honesty and nobility and courage and equates women’s honor with their vagina. We need to draw the firm line against all rape excuses, all justifications. We need to see men and women as equal sexual beings and demand the same levels of bodily autonomy for everyone. We need to treat everyone’s body – no matter what gender we attach to it – with dignity and respect.
All these misdirected hateful sentiments that have come out of Myriam’s attempted rape and murder, these racist feelings towards Syrian workers, these sectarian feelings, these vengeful feelings. We can understand the feelings. But we cannot condone how they are directed.
We honor Myriam’s memory by directing our anger at sexual violence. May she rest in peace and may the right justice be served. Fight rape.
| This entry was posted by Nadine on November 25, 2011 at 5:12 am, and is filed under Gender & Feminism, Personal Reflections. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
- Rest in Peace, Myriam Achkar: A Call Against Sexual Harrassment in the Arab World | And Far Away
- The Christian revolution of Sahel Alma « Lebanon Spring
- Siyese.com – Rest in peace, Myriam Achkar by Nadine Moawad
- Rest in Peace, Myriam Achkar : The Adventures of Salwa
- Monday Mining Culturtwining on the Web… random goodness | CultureTwined
- Lama’s Scrapbook: Myriam Achkar and the Collective Response
- When Little Red Riding Hood Becomes a Big Bad Wolf – Bekhsoos
- DSpeech Standalone
- Advanced Electrolysis Centre
- Rape is Rape: Lebanon Edition | The online sexual education













about 2 months ago
I AM SORRY FOR HER DEATH, BUT I DON’T BELIEVE IT HAS ANYTHING TO DO WITH CULTURE OR RILIGION DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE VICTIM OR THE MURDERER, WOMEN GET RAPE EVERYDAY OR MAYBE EVERY SECONDS IN ALL OVER THE WORLD BUT THE PROBLEM IN LEBANON OR OTHER ARAB SOCIEITES IS THAT THERE ARE NO LAWS THAT PROTECT WOMEN.IN OTHER WORDS IT IS THE MENTALITY THAT NEEDS TO CHANGE, IN WESTREN SOCIETY RAPED WOMEN IS BEING TREATED LIKE A VICTIM AND GET JUSTICE BUT IN THE ARAB WORLD THERE IS NO SUCH THING AND THIS IS THE ISSUE NOT IF THE LADY WAS CHRISTIAN AND THE ATTACKER WAS NOT
about 2 months ago
The problem is that this story is turning into racism at the end. We should not let it as U.S.A considers us a very racist country already.
about 2 months ago
Seriously Nadine?! You lost the credibility of this article by making it sound as RAPE case. This is a MURDER. Yes a murder, a crime, and whether it is obvious to you or not, a crime by a foreigner (a Syrian) on the Lebanese soil.
This may have nothing to do with Religion I agree, but hey I wanna see your recation when they hand the criminal to your loving neighboring country and he gets away with it! It is so easy to write like a Gandhi but totally not easy to be one, especially when you lost a FAMILY member. The reaction of her family is so understandable…..and had it been less than this on TV, it would have been abnormal!
I hope you post this comment….and thanks for the interesting info on rape and the Lebanese society laws. He should be brought to justice, and get what he deserves!
about 2 months ago
Thank you for writing this. I had the urge to write about the direction to which these blames were taking. People were steering away from the exact reason this happened, and they were channeling their anger onto different aspects. such as its nationality or religion. But you said it all here. Thanks again.
about 2 months ago
A simple internet search shows Lebanese being very civil to citizens of “host countries”, just as they are at home. Your average lot of gang rapes and such. We even made it into Wikipedia. So let’s focus on the brutality of the act now, and drop the witch hunt, shall we?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sydney_gang_rapes
“http://www.sierraexpressmedia.com/archives/20102″
http://www.topix.com/forum/world/australia/TDJBJ91EOC1RLD3MR
about 2 months ago
Superbe ! Il est temps de nommer les choses par leur nom.
about 2 months ago
Brilliant piece! Check out whiteribbon.org.au – a campaign to stop violence against women in Australia. One of the men leading the campaign is Hazem El Masri – he is an Australian footballer who was born in Lebanon.
about 2 months ago
Although some elements of truth is in it. It is part of the Aoun “in love syndrom with Syria”. Allow her parents to calm down, their daughter just died. Imagine this happened to your sister or daughter. In addition, what is happening in Zalka this week from theft and problems is a message from Syria. I know you will defend it. Aoun is the king in your opinion and all the rest are wrong.
about 2 months ago
Nadine you mentioned about rape in a marriage and between husband and wives and how it is considered normal and the woman cannot speak up. I do not live in lb but I saw on the news that most politicians for religious (muslim mainly and christian secondary) reasons disagreed the change of the law. Great job lebanese people. Keep up the good work. Sorry to say that but because of the stupidity of the lebanese people, politicians who are idiots and still living in 1700 are in. control of the governement and innocents are paying the price like in this sad story. So congratulations on keeping idiots controling ur life and sorry for the innocent people
about 2 months ago
excellent Nadine, thank you for speaking up, and like many I’m interested in any follow up action
about 2 months ago
You may be right on the last points of your article but this is way out of context anyway !
For your next article, please know better the topic before writing and publishing wrong information..
Rest in peace Myriam, we will never forget you
about 2 months ago
Let’s not try to civilize an uncivilized barbarian act and put in a clean context as if the crime happened in a place like London, Vienna… It happened in Sahel Alma
God forbid we call him Syrian, god forbid we call ourselves cristians but this scum of the earth didn’t forbid himself an attempt to rape Myriam and when he couldn’t silence her voice he then murdered her in cold blood, these are the facts
Would he dare doing what he did if he was in his hometown, let’s not hide the fact that some syrians think they have a free pass in Lebanon to steal, rape and kill, why Egyptians living in Lebanon don’t steal, kill or rape as the Syrians?
These are legitimate questions that you should ask yourself before criticizing the words of a family that is burdened by the biggest lost possible, her family and due to there strong belief in god they were able to give the best example of patience under these circumstances
Rape is intolerable no question about it and I am all for your suggestions but please let’s not disregard the place where all this took place
about 2 months ago
Dear,
I’m Myriam’s sister and i just had that time to read your twisted story.
With all my respect, I do ask you to fix your article because you are destroying Myriam’s spiritual and social message. MYRIAM WASN’T RAPED, and this was stated officially by the forensic doctor.
It’s true we are a christian family but we do ask for justice.
Thank you for understanding.
about 2 months ago
‘thirsts for his blood’??
Where is that coming from? How, in your head, did this issue turn from MANSLAUGHTER to RAPE and then witch hunt from a medieval, religiously sensitive society?
First of all, IF the village dwellers and family members were as backward thinkers as to ‘thirst for a foreigners blood’ as you so simply claim, they wouldnt have that foreigner working in their village in the first place, ever thaught about that?? Even more as a church custodian!
NO, it is NOT true we are a regressive society, NO, it is NOT true the issue has wrongfully turned into a ethnic/political one (in proper context, is IS so), NO, not ‘most, if not all’ women are more the daily victims of rape in lebanon than they are anywhere else in the world! ENOUGH over simplifying complex issues and spreading lies that are alien to this society!
So one family member, perhaps the victim’s brother or cousin, made a hateful comment in a spark of anger, and you turn an entire community into stone age barbarians!
You over reactive feminists make the rest of us who truly support positive change for women’s rights, sick to the guts!
about 2 months ago
I totally agree with Pascale….I am sorry but it is not a Rape case as stated above, though the info regarding the laws and social reality is good, it is not Myriam’s case. As Pascale said, it is a murder!!! she’s dead. As for the nationality and religious issue, i have one question that keeps popping in my mind, what a moukhabarat guy doing as a concierge?is this an undercover job? lebanese or syrian or whatever the result is the same, she’s dead and he’s a criminal! I just hope that he will get what he deserves and the gov won’t send him back to syria! it would be a shame on us!!!
about 2 months ago
Thank You Nadine for some sense finally! I thought people were going crazy…left and right talks about how we want to protect the Christian areas (for real?). It was not a Syrian attack on Lebanese, it was a psychotic man who raped an innocent girl and he should be trialed and put in jail….SHAME on everyone who is trying to make of this case a religious or even worse a Syrian attack. God rest Myriam’s soul and be with her family at this time of need! and God push away all those petty little men who feed off sectarian and nationalistic hatred!
about 2 months ago
Im lebanese and christian lebanese but since long time im out of lebanon but always following our lebanese news i understand the political situation this is not for us to juge well live for the politicians but this situation of our daughter i mean lebanese Myriam we have all the wrights to do a public juge not because this dirty fatih is not lebanese or not christian but because he touched the must howly for us as lebanese and as christians in the country where i live such pepole as this dirty FATIH JABER AL-SALATANI ok they judged him and put him in prison for at least 25 years in a special prison for such people where they dont live till the first year because down there theyll RAPPED him and will treat him as less than a dog Fatih ill wich you from all my heart such a punishment,your a shame for your coutry and your religion but such pepole as you they live without religion without country and without flag.Myriam let the god lord receive you between his huggs and im sure that you are next to Jesus Christ .
Dear Myriam let your solr rest in peace.
about 2 months ago
Why would we be surprised?! What do we expect from MEN in our country? They have all sectarian stereotypes, from religion to region to politics to class to SEX. This country is not heaven on earth as they call it, THIS COUNTRY IS PURE SHAME.
about 2 months ago
Although some of the ideas mentioned in the articles are true, but the majority of them are not true. First of all this is a crime, not a simple rape. You cannot ignore the circumstances when dealing with rape for example. You cannot treat a woman going to church, wearing decent clothes, praying and getting raped in the same way as a woman barely putting clothes on her, partying till dawn, half drunk and getting raped. I am not justifying the second situation, but I am saying that the conditions and the circumstances of the second situation influence dramatically and in a strong way the person to make a bad move towards the girl. It is absolutely not the same situation, and this is studied in the criminology and lots of articles prove that! There are 3 factors that form the triangle of crime (place, the victim and the attacker). And here you talk about the theory of opportunities. Therefore, you CANNOT treat what happened to Myriam in the same way that you deal with other situations, absolutely not.
Second, I DON’T agree that the nationality of the person doesn’t play a role since the majority of the crimes happening in Lebanon whether it is rape, kidnapping, theft, explosions, and murder are conducted by foreigners, specifically the neighbors whether it is Palestinians that take refuge in the camps or the Syrian workers. I am not saying that all the Palestinians or all the Syrians living in Lebanon are bad, but I am saying based on the statistics of the crimes committed, that these crimes are mostly committed by those type of people. Did you forget the recent case where a Syrian guy tried to rape a 70 year woman? Or the Iraqi person who tried to kidnap a child? Or the katarmaia crime committed by an Egyptian?? And so on and so on. Even in Switzerland, the majority of the crimes are committed by Africans, Moroccans and Non Swiss people. So, no, you cannot say that the fact that this crime was committed by a Syrian worker doesn’t affect the people judgment!. I do believe that these workers have sexual frustration, since it is not the first time that this thing happens in Lebanon!
I don’t believe that the death penalty is the right solution, and even Myriam’s mom said that she is against it, because we are Christians, and it is against our religion and believes to fight bad with bad. But I absolutely approve on applying the extreme punishment regime on this person so that others learn from him, that justice is served and nothing will go unpunished, in a human way and not in a barbaric non Christian way.
about 2 months ago
In the mist of your unintended (and I am sure it was unintended) contribution to the misdirection of Myriam Achkar’s murder, you have missed or misinterpreted some essential facts about this hideous crime.
1 – The phrase “rape and murder” that you have used many times throughout the article is not correct. Myriam LOST HER LIFE to stop that ruthless soulless criminal from abusing her. I’m sure a true feminist like you values the great difference between being “raped and murdered” and paying your life not to be raped. I urge you to correct this in your article and to highlight the correction as this fact is very worthy of clarification.
2 – Due to media abuse from different sides this sad event has been wrongfully directed. I’m sad to say that due to what we’ve seen on television and read on a few blogs in the past couple of days, the main discussion is now about how Myriam’s family and friends mentioned religion and asked for revenge while we should be directing our attention to the quick prosecution and sentencing of the true criminal. How dare we analyze and dissect the words of a family on their way to bid their brutally murdered sister/daughter farewell?! It is not you who should be blamed for commenting this way, but those who wrongfully created and showcased this whole situation. I wish we can postpone the sectarian and counter sectarian lecturing to a time where they do not affect the true course that this case should be taking.
3- It is true that the fact that Myriam was a Christian and her murderer was Syrian had nothing to do with the murder, or at least this is what we know! However, there was news about the interest of the Syrian authorities in releasing the murderer and the multiple attempts to free him even before the poor girl was buried. As well we have heard yesterday about attempts to revive a certain prisoner exchange agreement between the two countries for this exact purpose! I hope that we, as modern civilized Lebanese citizens will be able to take care of our own victim the way the criminal’s country is taking care of him despite all the trouble occurring in Syria recently.
AWAY from Politics, Religion and Sectarian backgrounds, I hope you will be able to shed the light on these important facts, because human rights as well as our Patriotic duty to provide justice to our friend and peer Myriam (May she rest in peace) definitely have priority over our conclusions and analysis of a certain video or reportage we’ve seen on TV. Please help us bring this case back to where it should be before discussing how we should all react in a perfect world.
Here’s the opinion of Myriam’s friends and family from a different angle if it might interest you to see it :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRxVMVV0sqc
about 2 months ago
Just to clarify: It was ATTEMPTED rape not actual rape… Myriam prevented the murdered from taking her virtue.
Also, the family doesn’t “thirst for his blood” on the contrary they forgave him & only want to ensure that justice is accomplished.
It’s really unfair how the truth is being twisted!!!
The main idea of your article is very important: Crime is not acceptable no matter the circumstance. However, it makes it even worse that the murderer was not a local; he -& many other- can enter our country with no need for a background or security check
about 2 months ago
Thank you Nadine, and I would like to congratualte Pascal on her future telling skills, as she seem certain that he will be handed over, second would like to remind her that there were over 20 Syrian Workers murdered in Lebanon in he last 5 years, and no one even mentioned them, there is a racism here that is not tolerated, if the criminal was Lebanese or French this would have not even made it to tv and this is the highest level of hypocrisy
about 2 months ago
Finally we r speaking up!!
1st may her soul rest in peace…
2nd let me say great article, keep it up ppl,
3rd i have to say that u’re right, religion and nationality has nothing to do with whatever happened to Myriam and other million Lebanese girls and women but if we r naming the things let’s not forget that 5, 10 maybe more chapters of our harassment struggle with every Lebanese woman included the workers and illegal alien that does exist in Lebanon bel habal!!!
about 2 months ago
Nadine,
Speak Up always
Thumbs Up
about 2 months ago
Myriam may your soul rest in peace,
For the article every single word you said about raping, police and situations si so true and we’ve all been there,
But let me tell you something about that she is Christian and he’s Syrian,
this is the fact and what happened! and he was a undercover agent for Syria, do you know how many same story does exist in Lebanon with those ppl, lets not deny the facts that Syrian& Egyptian workers are a huge section in that problem,
anyway in my personal opinion is to focus more about getting justice for myriam and safety for the Lebanese girls and woman.
He should be burned alive. I swear I can’t stop myself. (this is the justice)
about 2 months ago
You know what encourages police the way they act too? The fact that some girls who want to pressure their parents into marrying a guy, sleep with them, then file for rape, because of the marriage law. Sad but true. Imagine what this does to a real rape victims in case they present their case (on top of all you said).
I think the identification of a rape crime should be taught to police officers, women police officers should be hired for these cases because they can relate more and they can be more comfort to a rape victim. Men should be taught not to blame a victim.
I do believe that sometimes you can avoid risky situations, but even if you don’t it does not make rape right.
The saddest part I noticed is that women are the ones who carry on the tradition of blaming other women. And last but not least women themselves in Lebanon think it is okay to present an objectification of the body and consider it as a liberation and a right, while we miss much more important rights.
Men never gave women their rights, women are the ones who took them.
about 2 months ago
Thank you for the update
about 2 months ago
Nadine, i agree with with the lady (Sandra frem) 100%, in what she stated… and one more thing, the family is such a peaceful family… they have no thirst for his blood (please pick ur words well). Other than that, yes we should fight against rape and against our stupid system and police that give no interest in rape cases. unfortunately!
about 2 months ago
Hello Nadine,
Lovely article, very well put words, though you turned a heinous crime into a rape. Sorry to remind you but the poor girl was brutaly murdered not raped and we all ;lebanese people; want to avenge this death no matter if he’s syrian or whatever nationality. Please, do not undermine this crime.
about 2 months ago
There is something really wrong with those who are outraged by the murder. Yes it is a horrible crime, and whoever did it should be punished, but since when a crime does represent a whole nation? For D who said that Egyptians don’t rape, probably didn’t know that yes Egyptians on Lebanese soil do rape, and in fact one was lynched by an angry mob in a village in Iklim l Kharoub after he raped a girl. So yes Mr/Miss, all foreigners on Lebanese soil are capable of crime, but when a Syrian does it it becomes a matter of racism and politics, in fact MTV the most stupid and racist TV channel talked frankly of a Syrian agenda to terrorize Christian areas. So the crime is horrible, but using this crime for political and racist motives is just as horrible. Anyway, media vomit in Lebanon is sickening. I am sure the rapist would have raped if he were in Mecca doing the Hajj, please guys and girls, understand a simple fact, even in the most liberal and sexually open societies rapes occur. It is a sad reality, but it’s a reality.
Anyway, I am sure those with a firm hatred for Syria and the Syrians, will not care, this crime will be another puzzle in their hatred justification puzzle. Whatever, those who look for the bigger picture will know how to separate things. I am still appalled by the Lebanese media, it is simply racist beyond belief, as if there’s no restraint and no true attempt to understand anything.
about 2 months ago
the guy needs to die.. the same way he killed her or even worse. and dont forget that he works with syria, spy, living in lebanon. thats enough.
about 2 months ago
Hi Nadine.
You have made some good points but I hope you are reading and taking in the comments posted here.
While you say we need to educate the Lebanese about this and improve safety on the streets, and change our “sexist culture”, this is true, BUT DO YOU EXPECT US TO EDUCATE OTHER CULTURES AS WELL?
How can we control the sexist thoughts or stares of Syrian workers who hang out on almost every street in Jounieh? Who is coming and leaving our country? WE HAVE POOR BORDER CONTROLS and Lebanon is known to be the “SAFEHAVEN” of exiled people, of extremism and otherwise.
As someone who has lived in Jounieh and Sahel Alma, I urge you to be careful with your words. While you see the family’s statements as “misdirected sentiments”, they are very important and valid in many ways, which you need to consider and accept.
Any racism that may branch of their statements is the result of something else.
Lea and Sami’s comments above make a very good point. Please take your thoughtful commenters into account and re-evaluate your post.
about 2 months ago
1-Whether she was raped or not, the point is she was murdered BECAUSE the bastard wanted to rape her. The attempted rape is the cause of the murder.
2-As someone who was born and raised in Jounieh, ALL men there can be jerks/rapists (simply because the laws don’t prevent them from harassing women on the streets. Women are even harassed by the police and the army there!)
3-Whether I was wearing a skirt or jogging in my masculine baggy sweatsuit, the level of harassment, humiliation and disgusting sexual innuendos is always the same… And most of the people who are doing that are young Lebanese men (I always guess from their accents and their rich daddies’ cars!)
4-The fact that a virtuous woman on her way to pray was attacked and murdered is proof enough that the victim does NOT control what the criminals do. He wanted to have sex with her REGARDLESS of her virtue or garment. It’s funny that some commentators took offense because the article considers that whether a woman was naked, drunk or a saint, a rape is a rape and the victim is a victim.
about 2 months ago
Hi Nadine
Whether Myriam Achkar was raped or not is no longer pertinent since she was Killed.
Is being raped worse than being dead?
With due respect to all previous opinions and comments mine is that the worse happenned: Myriam violently lost her life because of either rape or attempted rape. The 1st call for War should be on Rape whoever the perpetrator is and whatever his nationality.Please don’t tell me that among the lebanese there are no rapists !
The 2nd call for War should be on the perception both our society in its various chapters ,the legal one included , has of a raped woman
Thank you for you article since you had the courage to address the real issues around which this tragedy revolves.
As for the punishement, I am not ashamed to say, contrary to the modern outlook ,that it is “an eye for an eye”.
Myriam’s story is one where capital punishement imposes itself.
about 2 months ago
rape??? r u serious!!!!
whoever he is whatever nationality he couldve been a blue eyed sweedish for all i care…. HE MUST BE LYNCHED!! YES IN THE JOUNIEH SQUARE AND YES HE MUST BE HANGED HIGH FOR THE WORLD TO SEE!!!
this is a cruel world that needs cruel measures!!! and pls dont start with human rights nonesense… khlosna bala ta3me!! what about her rights!!! what about her dignity!! LYNCH THE DAMN BASTARD!!! that’s the only way to get crime rates down!!!
about 2 months ago
Hello Everyone
I have just read the article by mistake and I appreciated the opposing comments. This is what increases awareness and allows us to read each other’s opinion and get the chance to think about it. Sadly, some of the commentators seem to be very closed on their opinions while they should lighten up.
As C said, and I admire the knowledge behind his comment, there was a reason behind the murder, attempted rape, and it is the case to be addressed at first.
As for Rafic, Lebanon was always in favor of capital punishment, and this has never reduced the crime rates in Lebanon. Believe it or not, it did not reduce it in any of the states/countries that support it.
It can only lead to additional hatred, just what his comment was full of.
The article was clear in pointing out an idea using the latest crime that happened to back it up, which is a typical way of forcing changes in laws and social regulations.
Thank you
about 2 months ago
Great article!!! Concerning the above comments….Some people just read without understanding the message and they comment stupidly according to their low comprehension levels!!! People when you want to comment make sure that you understand first!!!
about 2 months ago
My heart for the family. Understood the anger. But crime actually has no religion! – Ann from Singapore, it is happening everywhere, even here.
about 2 months ago
Brilliant ..
about 2 months ago
Just as the people of Ketermeya took justice in their own hands and gave that sick excuse of a human what he deserves by hanging in the village square, this syrian deserves nothing less.
Turning the other cheek should not apply here…let him get his punishment from us and from Allah…
about 2 months ago
one question to BE
..and what about the countries where capital punishement has been abolished and where criminals are released under controlled surveillance,has the crime rate decreased or do we not see repeated instances where the criminal is just given another chance to repeat his crimes.
As for hate, yes when there is such a hateful incident Hate is in order ,because it is not free -Hate for no reason- it is Hate instigated by a hateful act
about 2 months ago
First, I would like to offer prayers and my deepest condolences to the family of the martyr who fought her cowardly attacker with all she had. The Lord bless you and give you strength to endure this terrible ordeal.
I urge women to learn how to protect themselves, not only from rapists, but also from muggers, criminals, abusive boyfriends, and other “men”.
As a man who respects women and want them to live safe and fulfilling lives, it is my duty to share whatever knowledge and skill-set i have. Thus, I am giving free self defense training to all women who are interested in attending our “Safe For Life” seminars.
Check the schedule on http://www.senshido.net/events.php
Take care, stay safe, and God bless.
G.
about 2 months ago
I believe we are all very clear that the big picture the final picture, the end product is murder, yes! But that came last.
But what led there is the rape, the initial intent of this person was rape, it started with the idea of rape , the attempt to rape was the main cause that lead to the murder of this young woman who fought courageously till her last breath.
I was born and raised in Lebanon, and I only have one thing to say, why are we protecting lebanese rapists molesters?
Any objectors don’t even get me started! Ohhh don’t even get me counting!
Why is it that women are so afraid to come out and say this F**KING bastered raped me, tried to rape me. WHY ARE WE NOT ANGRY AGOUT IT!
With the older generation of women standing by not saying anything, you are only teaching your daughters that rape is ok, it happens, we don’t talk about it, and that’s ok! ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
and I want to add a filthy pig is a filthy pig, they will attempt at you day or night, people or no people, on the street, in a taxi, on the bus, even if you are in your own car, and they can’t see anything but your face!
We need do something to protect the women and especially, especially the children are little ones,pure of heart they should be educated and know what is acceptable and what is not acceptable behavior to expect from any person, no matter what the age!
If a survey needs to be done then let’s do it, let’s go out on the streets and get people to fill out form, anonymous drop them in black boxes, let’s find out, and show them what the percentages are and what the ages are of the people affected by rape in Lebanon! I will come back there just for this!
My condolences to the family of Myriam Achkar,, revenge is not the answer is all I can say to the family. If so then you are only putting yourself at the same level as the filthy low life that murdered your daughter, I do hope that he gets caught and put to justice, and rots in jail for the rest of his miserable life !
about 2 months ago
This is one of the few rational articles I read regarding the murder. Great job nadz, I wish more people were like you.