How We Trended #Gaza on Twitter
I made some edits (in red) on December 28.
We did it! We trended #Gaza on twitter on the day that commemorated the start of the brutal 22-day Israeli war and siege on Gaza. It was an incredible day. #Gaza trended into the Top 10 for a good 9 hours at least (at the time of writing this post). Wow. So a quick recap of how it went:
- By Sunday morning, we had 74 people signed up to tweet for Gaza between 5pm and 9pm.
- I got online around noon and saw that Gaza had already risen to 0.4% Many tweeps were already online tweeting heavily for Gaza. @gyonis suggested that we try and get half-way up the trending chart by the start of the campaign. @justicentric and @smileandsubvert were tweeting insanely. Spirits were high and more people were getting online and tweeting for Gaza. Some had prepared tweets beforehand, which was very smart. And then, around 1.30 pm, #Gaza appeared on the Top 10 Trending Topics of Twitter! Of course, @justicentric was the first to notice it, cos he was monitoring all the stats like a hawk. A bit before 2pm, it was at #9:
- We went insane! We ran around (metaphorically, on twitter) not knowing what to do. We had broken into the Trending 10 already, so we couldn’t stop. We had to keep on going. Everyone was nailed to their computers or phones, tweeting, re-tweeting, linking, sharing. And @Palaestina who had AMAZING tweets lined up, including the names of every child who was killed in Gaza, got blocked. Barely after s/he warned us about it, other active members, included myself, also got blocked. We opened new accounts immediately and tweeted from there until they unblocked our accounts (which was an average of 45 minutes later). @uruknet and other tweeps reported getting blocked for up to 3.5 hours. The blocking was fishy and didn’t make a lot of sense, so you can see some ideas being bounced in the comments about why this happened. I definitely think we were being reported by people who didn’t want #Gaza to trend.
- Very quickly, #Gaza fluctuated between #7 and #8 on twitter. Hopes were very high! We couldn’t believe we had made it so early on. Over 300 tweeps had signed on to the #Gaza twibbon.
- Everything was going great.. It was close to 4pm and we were at #5! We were figuring out the techniques of trending something on twitter. Multiple hashes don’t count. The new RT function doesn’t count. Too many RTs get you blocked or helps your rivals report you as spam. Zionist assholes started showing up and promoting us all as anti-Semites. People were waking up and asking what #Gaza meant. It was awesome! This screenshot is me tweeting from my other account (cos twitter blocked me, remember?) That’s why it’s in blue:
- People were logging in and feeling so energized to see Gaza trending already, so they boosted with great tweets. I was so sure we were going to hit number one any second. And then came Hayley.
- Who Hayley is I don’t know and I don’t care to google. It was her birthday today, so suddenly (and very illogically), HappyBdayHayley shot to number 1. It didn’t make any sense! Look at the difference between #Gaza and #HappyBdayHaley on trendistic in the screenshot below. That’s us in red. How could #HappyBdayHayley shoot to number one? What made it even weirder is that @zalface discovered many spam bots like this one: @carolmeatsix that were spamming twitter with #HappyBdayHayley for hours at very high rates. How come they didn’t get blocked? This adds to our suspicion that we were being reported by people.
- The only sense we could make was that twitter didn’t want #Gaza to trend. And after HappyBdayHayley came HappyBdayHayleyBR – the Brazilian version – also trending! Ridiculous! But still, the tweeters kept signing on, news, links, videos, feelings, thoughts, cartoons, blog posts, stories, all sorts of expressions kept flowing onto twitter, all for Gaza, the Gaza Freedom March, and Viva Palestina. Eventually, we made it to #3. Yep. We hit Trending Topic Number 3 on twitter at 7:39 (+2GMT). Here’s the screenshot!
- We tried really hard after that, but couldn’t get it past #3. I believe we were stopped there on purpose. Further proof is that twitter never allowed #Gaza to appear on its main page for before you sign in. I watched it for more than 10 hours. Even when we hit and stayed on the top 5, #Gaza never showed on the main twitter.com. I was actually corrected about this by @Stand4Liberty who sent me a screenshot (below) of #Gaza appearing on the sign-in page briefly when we were top-trending. Did twitter block #Gaza from getting to #1 on purpose? Maybe, maybe not. I really don’t know. I do, however, think it is pointless to waste our time wondering if it did. We still trended for > 10 hours!
- We kept on tweeting through the night. By 11pm, #Gaza had dropped off the Top Ten Trending completely, but is still going pretty well. All in all, the feeling of being part of this campaign was amazing! We trended by the time the tweeters in North American (twitter’s largest demographic) woke up. Lots of people said they learned a lot about Gaza and Palestine today. We outnumbered the Zionist tweeters by far. By the time of posting, people who supported the #Gaza twibbon were 460 and their total followers were 379,307. @justicentric says he got over 10,000 clicks on the links he put out today, not including the links from re-tweets. @Razaniyyat and @uruknet‘s tweets were loaded with informative links and resources. @MXML wasn’t online but s/he scheduled beautifully thought-provoking tweets about Palestine and Gaza. @GhadeerM tweeted for Gaza from all her heart – although only last week she didn’t know what twitter was. There was something beautiful in all of us, strangers, coming together, from all over the world, talking collectively about a cause that matters to us, achieving a goal together. Solidarity. Using a new, creative, youthful strategy. Away from the usual rhetoric, the usual groups, politicians, and religions that hijack the Palestinian cause.
- What comes next, I’m not sure. But we’ve found each other and we’ve accomplished something together with the help of very little: a couple of blog posts, a few tweets, and a google document. Let’s all watch and tweet for the Gaza Freedom March for the next week, and all ideas of what activism we can come up with using this new network we’ve created are welcome. Make sure you join the Palestine Action Network on Facebook so we can contact you later for other campaign ideas! Thank you everybody!
I end with a beautiful tweet from @ajit8uk that just came up:
“We got to 3. We are the people. No one owns this earth. NO ONE. #GAZA”
…
—-









Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by nmoawad: How We Trended #Gaza on Twitter http://www.nadinemoawad.com/2009/12/how-we-trended-gaza-on-twitter/ #Palestine #GFM…
Thank you for all of your hard work, Nadine.
As for those who got blocked for short periods: It seems that it was not Twitter automatically doing it, rather, if a certain number of people reports someone as spam (which could be done nefariously – as in prodded by the @JIDF or someone else, or because they actually see it as spam (e.g. lots of @s in a tweet), Twitter will auto-block then review the account. It happened to people who were “tweeting for Shalit” too, so I don’t think we can say it was biased, necessarily.
Razan left me a note on FB. I just got on FB this month after a lot of people asking me to, and me being wary… with the site, I thought it would kill off all my activism time, (which to some extent it does) but I am glad I’m there. So, I figured out how to use Twitter this afternoon! This was my baptism in Twitter and I still don’t know how important the Trending is, but I take your word, that it must mean something seeing how the Red Line there got all of a sudden swallowed up by something called Hayley? So yes, i can see they saw this as a threat. So being on the radar in this way must be a good achievement and I am happy to have been part of it.
Include me in the next series, (hopefully I will be faster and better and have things lined up, I learned after the big peak how to put in quick links… )
Really happy that something positive has been done: showing that our voices are going to be out there.
Congrats and it was nice to share this moment. Kisses from Italy
Hi Nadine; well done today! I wish I was home so I could have joined (unfortunately my mobile is not geeky enough for me to tweet on the move)
Just FYI, in case you’re still wondering, Harley is in fact http://twitter.com/yelyahwilliams
Again, great job today!
I think Jillian’s comment makes sense. The blockings don’t make any sense at all. I was tweeting and RT-ing a lot more frequently later and was not blocked. Also many robots like this http://twitter.com/carolmeatsix were probably created to boost popularity of Hayley and were spamming ridiculously. So I guess we were probably reported. @uruknet who was 84th rank on http://www.retweetrank.com/ for today was blocked for 3.5 hours – whereas others were blocked for 30-40 mins.
I’d hate to think that Twitter blocked #Gaza today.
But as someone said in an email today:
“… if the US Govt can postpone Twitter’s scheduled maintenance during #IranElection, why couldn’t they block #Gaza for equally convenient political purposes?”
Interestingly, Twitter’s review of 2009 shows “Gaza” as no.3 in the News Events:
1. #iranelection
2. Swine Flu
3. Gaza
4. Iran
…
http://blog.twitter.com/2009/12/top-twitter-trends-of-2009.html
Great work Nadine!
http://twitter.com/ReadingPSC
Keep up with VP Convoy news here:
http://readingpsc.org.uk/convoy
http://twitter.com/ReadingPSC/vp3
Excellent Work
I had troubles accessing the internet yesterday (had none actually where I was) but managed to squeeze a tweet from the mobile..
Great Job Nadine..Great Job
This is a great account of how you all campaigned via twitter to make Gaza one of the most discussed topics so that people don’t forget the Israeli attack on Gaza and its continuing effects. I will share your blogs regarding this campaign including this one with my students (as a part of their reading assignment for my Digital Media and Culture course) to show them the ways in which social media can be used for increasing awareness, influencing social & political agenda and in social movements of course. I personally enjoyed sharing the moment and seeing Gaza as a trending topic on twitter. Many thanks.
[...] efforts – #gaza reached number 3 on the trending topics. Check this link out to know more: How we Trended #Gaza on Twitter . Remember: The only international crimes that people get away with are the one’s that no one [...]
I’m really proud to be part of this…
well written blog……am very impressed.
never knew about it before….will follow on twitter and rss. thanks for samih toukan for tweeting the link……..good job nadine…..
Mahd
[...] occurred around the world. An effort to make Gaza a “trending topic” on Twitter succeeded but faded in less than a [...]
Nadine,
One thing that might explain the discrepancy between Trendistic and Trending Topics in Twitter is the different algorithms they use. Twitter’s Trending Topics is not only based on the number of tweets, but also the number of tweepers. It is also more difficult for topics that are trendy all the time to climb up the list (Twitter is, after all, about what is hot RIGHT NOW!). If you look at the longer term graph, you will see that Gaza has been consistently trendier than Bailey, Hayley or whatever her name is. It is self-defeating in a way. Other than that, I am not sure exactly how it works, but finding out could be useful for future action.
Anyway, I don’t think it matters that Gaza was not number 1. The important thing is that you got Gaza up there and it was a great campaign. Ya3teekon alf 3afiyeh.
Awesome, Nadine. I felt a kind of frenzy after the first hour tweeting, the amazing feeling of being immersed into a hot bath of Gaza-empathy. I learnt a lot from the advice offered throughout the campaign from people like Jillian on how to tweet responsibly and effectively -http://bit.ly/4IOx2D and, like you said, tried to tweet with moderation. I´m so proud of all of you and love to be part of this community. Count on me anytime
I was sooo surprised not to see Gaza at Twitter’s main page, I couldn’t believe it. I saw it trending in the top 5 and it just didn’t show on the main page! Outrageous!
I LOVED this.
I felt the adrenaline rising in me just reading it.
maybe i shud create a twitter account!
Hugs and kisses comrade!
I’m really proud of everyone and I am so happy that I could contribute as well. Thanks so much for setting this up. I’m sure the Gazans appreciated it.
My Twitter was so flooded with tweets that I kept getting “Temporary Service Unavailable” at times!
Wonderful! tho i only rt, there was much info i learned. we are brainwashed in the usa and news doesnt report half of the truth. worldpeace2day had plethora of info that was unique(im surprised you didnt mention this). keep up the good work on information and indeed, do it again.
well done nadiall ur true inspiration 2 all of us thankkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk u so much..wishing u the best n 2010 and for everyone on ths earth who call out for real justice xo
[...] an extensive analysis, Lebanese blogger, Nadine Moawad, accused Twitter of preventing #Gaza from trending: People were logging in and feeling so energized [...]
[...] an extensive analysis, Lebanese blogger, Nadine Moawad, accused Twitter of preventing #Gaza from trending: People were logging in and feeling so energized [...]
[...] uma extensa análise, o blogueiro libanês Nadine Moawad acusou o Twitter de prevenir que #Gaza continuasse crescendo nos tópicos em tendência: People [...]
[...] These forms of live-reporting from Twitter can be seen as acts of citizen-journalism, the use of Twitter in the recent Gaza protests in Cairo are importantly distinct. Here trending and a focus on strategically driving issues to the top of the Twitter community was of central importance, not solely the acts of citizen-journalism that defined Twitter’s use in the Iranian protests. The details of twitter-trending as an act of protest are explained in detail by Nadine Moawad in “How we Trended #Gaza on Twitter“: [...]
[...] rights today. Google him. The decision was unanimous! It was like an awesome reunion of all the #Gaza tweeters – all of us spreading the word from 2am (Beirut time) till now – which is 8am. [...]
Amazing piece, I love the chronological flow of the story, where were I when all this happened? Keep up the great work
[...] Nowadays, people like you and I have our share. Read how few talented and devoted activists made #Gaza trend worldwide on Twitter to raise awareness about essential human rights violations by [...]